The Sudden Impulse by Bernt Stellander

Pat Brown's opinion, rather long winded nonetheless interesting.  Nothing wrong with hearing another theory, I look forward to knowing what mystery man has to say.

BEWARE the New Madeleine McCann Book!!!

The book mentioned by Pat Brown has been a long time in the making.

This video is from 2022.

Only 3 days before the foreign detective's book is published.

the foreign detective has shed his costume drama, name will seep out later i think. but the book is called; sudden impulse. there is quite vague video , i can get the sound not in a version i can hear.
so most is now on twitter.

this version has 2 may for ending up dead, and a grave somewhere near rocha negra or negro.

but it is twitter so not really a story, just snippets.

The release date to coincide with the anniversary of Maddie's disappearance is suspicious in itself imo.

Full marks to Pat for agreeing to read the book - the sheer length of it puts me off, not to mention the silly disguise.

Perhaps we will be pleasantly surprised by the contents though I won't put a bet on it.

Agreed, I think Pat Brown is just being nice. Until the next time.

I certainly won't be putting money in the foreign detectives pocket only to reveal yet another baseless theory. I am however interested to know his 2nd May theory and burial location and of course his true identity.

17 years down the line is a bit far fetched for my liking, another money making venture?

The initial Metro report published a month ago said:

https://metro.co.uk/2024/04/07/new-madeleine-mccann-book-will-claim-missing-tot-already-dead-20601488/

>> A new book on missing tot Madeleine McCann will claim she is dead and point to the place her remains are ‘very likely hidden’.

Portuguese publisher Modocromia is preparing to launch the near-800-page book with ‘photos and maps’ on May 2.

The Lisbon-based firm says it is keeping the name of the author under wraps for the time being and is only referring to him as a ‘foreign detective’.

The English-speaking investigator has given a bizarre interview ahead of the book’s official presentation, wearing sunglasses and a black hoodie with the word ‘Truth’ emblazoned on the front.

He told host Dietmar Goetz on a show called Nightfly Private Talks Only broadcast on YouTube that his discoveries during a years-long investigation were a ‘game changer’.

He said he was ‘sure’ Madeleine was dead before adding: ‘The truth will come out with this book, the case will be solved and Maddie’s remains will be found.

‘The house of cards will fall with this book and it will be revealed by those who buried her but yes, there is a very high probability that I know where that is.’

He said he has contacted police, but did not receive a response, before going on to describe chief suspect Christian Brueckner, currently being tried in Germany for unrelated sex crimes he allegedly committed on the Algarve, as a scapegoat.

The interview is being used by the Portuguese publishers planning on releasing the book to promote it – but it was not immediately clear where and how the book will be sold.

A spokesman for Modocromia said copies would be made available in English and Portuguese during a press conference launch on May 2 at the Vila Gale Hotel in Lagos.

The publishers said in a marketing blurb for the book released yesterday: ‘A seven-year investigation has come to an end and shocking new evidence will be revealed, including the new timeline and actual time of death of Madeleine McCann, where Maddie was hidden for weeks, and where Maddie’s remains are very likely hidden.’

In a statement on its Facebook site, it added: ‘Modocromia Publishing has signed a contract with The Foreign Detective to publish a book that tells the truth about the Madeleine McCann case.’

Madeleine McCann’s parents previously lost a legal battle over a hurtful book called ‘Maddie: The Truth of Lie’ by controversial former PJ chief Amaral.

The couple took him to the European Court of Human Rights after years of litigation in his homeland over the book which accused them of covering up Madeleine McCann’s ‘accidental’ death.

The court upheld a freedom-of-expression decision by Portugal’s Supreme Court in September 2022.

Amaral launched a fresh attack on the McCanns by claiming they were ‘still suspects’ over their daughter’s disappearance in a subsequent Portuguese radio interview.

That was despite them having their ‘arguido’ status lifted more than 15 years ago and Brueckner becoming the current sole suspect.

It is not known if Amaral contributed in any way to the new book. <<

Gerard Couzens again?

Bit cloak and dagger isn't it, all will be revealed.

the name of the writer of the new book is made known, his name is bernt stellander, the book is titled sudden impulse.

supposedly he is from norway. but there looks to be little online je about the book or the writer.

it is said to have quite a lot of pages, but as some made known to read the book and review it, it would be come out what kind of theory he follows on. it was said over 800 pages, so that would need a bit of time.

bild has the first article out, but behind the paywall, but i could grab this and translated it through deepl;

03/05/2024 - 21:01
Just in time for the 17th anniversary of her disappearance, an amateur investigator claims: I have solved the case of the missing Madeleine McCann.
He presents his "evidence" in a new book. Find out with BILDplus what daring theory the ex-military policeman puts forward about the night of the crime, who he thinks is the real culprit - and where Maddie's body could be hidden.

What's the thoughts on this?
https://youtu.be/uMtL7P6yDRQ?si=XBDlacR9BZceFhEK

From watching the video in itself there doesn't seem to be anything that hasn't already been debated across social media over the years. The story so far looks like a compilation of various sources of information concentrating mainly on statement analysis and speculative theory.

Perhaps the book reveals more.

AlloAllo wrote:From watching the video in itself there doesn't seem to be anything that hasn't already been debated across social media over the years.  The story so far looks like a compilation of various sources of information concentrating mainly on statement analysis and speculative theory.

Perhaps the book reveals more.  

It may very well be nothing new to those stalwarts however at 800 pages I'd hope there might be something in it for us. It seems pretty obvious that his identified final resting place can't be correct and after 17 years the ground wouldn't look any different from the surroundings. The camera angle could be interesting though, at least it might highlight the inconsistencies to those who are not aware.

i agree, it is simply wait and see. it is not the first who wrote a book telling he or she solved the case. but it would be nice to see how he arrived on his points.

graves can change the ground above for always, at least that is how war graves often are found back.
i know some of the guys who did that as a second job. we have a special military based unit to do that work, together with civil experts. many of the information still comes from that work, nowadays the body farms are great too. both give often well informed sites, like date of burial, and that can help, but still the only proven way is still dig and find, but not just by anyone with a spade.

it certainly is an area with a lot of potential to hide a body long term.

i have a bit of a problem we get 'danny k. mr dna machine back in this story'. getting a patent on something is not that difficult, you only have to bring on an original concept and pay for the patent, you do not have to show it works, or even exist.
it also one of many that put out references that can hardly be traces back to them.
people have already a lot of problems with the work of dogs, this lacks all research.

a lot of points touched on during the book launch i do agree on, that they worth to take a look at, but words as prove is always hard. for me it does not have that urgent need to be placed one day before, earlier gives simply more time, and opens up more possibilities, but if this is the grave site, i think it still could be done on thursday too.

i do agree the tapas 7 know what happened or have at least a good idea, but if they are implicated before the 'alarm to the gnr' moment or after for the first days simple been used, can still be possible.
sen that many times before, helping hands without knowing why the help was taken en you could call it reven abused. still they are not stupid people, they could have seen enough to put 1 and 1 together in a 2.

sudden impuls i used myself in my write up about fitting it just on the thursday evening. and usually doing stupid things are finding their foundation in sudden impulses . and could even be called the motivation. i used in all my never published write ups from all other zero hour points.
it is typical human behaviour to do first, think later.

during his presentation indeed there had been little fresh points outed, would be hard to after all words already spend on this case.

the possible grave site is already documented in a more loose way by a piece of ben salmon.

https://h42a.wordpress.com/2016/12/28/black/?fbclid=IwZXh0bgNhZW0CMTEAAR2VWknKFmZhRQ-MyZtIUXmKtZnnLhR0Ojo81v_NAfGWBghW_WKiAEthE_w_aem_AZvbLIzpQ8vMzfRmLYAsz8f8dlqEVnH3QLdJPSLpuo8YctjLBM-WLtLGs2jcG6LUeejByDct72qbhLCkvjIarago

there is a another chapter with corrections, he used a lot of the information from kiko about the phones to. both passed away now sadly.

so for me it is a wait and see. the case itself simply has very little facts and known circumstances that are secure enough to include or exclude all theories you can think off. and even finding the remains is not prove the way as you thought it out is the right one.
finding a grave with the remains would at least tell she died, after so many years very hard to put a date and time on that. cause of death only by sheer luck.
but the full story before and after still has mostly to be told by the adults around her that week, and if that will be really the truth, or just a version that can serve as reputation saver maybe will be the forever question.

the pr of the guy started out pretty meager, but he had a good grip on this one. still a bit too much showing of, i never like that in possible criminal cases. but that is just me.

it can hardly inflict the ongoing trials in germany, but it would be quite a watch how it gets a following up in the uk media. the germans already picked it up.

I've given this book its own topic as it does seem that, despite mine and others' scepticism, it is worth reading.

I'll put a link to the other forum where are lots of comments.

https://jillhavern.forumotion.net/t17551-norwegian-ex-military-detective-claims-to-have-solved-madeleine-case

I've just watched a podcast with him telling all about it, quite interesting if you have the time... I watched it sped up.

https://youtu.be/-AtUT5BO3e4?si=RMmdsQEzjilGxkyl

I was about to post it myself. The length of it puts me off but I will give it a go.

So do you think he is believable?

His theory of where she is is a bit too close I think but there's quite a few nuggets in there also. Worth the watch I think.

I must admit that I am now thinking this is a load of B S, which coincidentally is his initials! It's very hard to explain but I simply don't understand what he says most of the time; not a language problem as his English is great but he seems to talk in riddles. I am looking forward to listening to Pat Brown's review of his book, to see if she changes my mind.

Another mystery is why the McCanns haven't come down on him like a ton of bricks as they did with Pat Brown and Tony Bennett, for example. Is the answer simply that the book is such nonsense that they have no worries that anyone will believe it?

Thanks for that. I'm not convinced that Mr S is in the least bit believable. As you said, Freedom, wouldn't the McCanns have set the dogs on him (Carter-Ruck) if there was any substance in what he said.